
Patent office actions can be intimidating, especially when you’ve invested time and money into protecting your invention. But receiving a rejection doesn’t necessarily mean the end of your patent journey.
In this episode of the Bold Inventor Show, J.D. Houvener, founder of Bold Patents, and co-host Matt Kulseth break down what happens after you file a patent application, why the USPTO issues office actions, and how inventors can respond.
The hosts also answer live questions about trademarking slogans, keeping patent applications confidential, and protecting new product brands. To bring everything together, they examine GeoOrbital, an electric bicycle wheel company featured on Shark Tank, and explore what happened to its patent and trademark applications.
Whether you’re preparing to file your first patent or already navigating the USPTO examination process, this episode offers practical insights into protecting your intellectual property.
Bold Inventor Show: Patent Office Actions, Trademark Protection, and the GeoOrbital Case Study
J.D. Houvener: Afternoon, everybody! Welcome to the Bold Inventor Show. I’m J.D. Houvener, owner of Bold Patents Law Firm, and we’ve got my co-host, Matt Kulseth, with us today.
Matt: Good morning, good afternoon! We’ve got an action-packed show for you. Maybe you’re facing an office action. Have you filed your own patent application and received a rejection from a USPTO examiner? Now might be the time to seek professional guidance.
J.D.: That’s right. We’re broadcasting live on YouTube, LinkedIn, and Facebook. We’ll welcome questions as they come in. Today’s main topic is office actions, but your questions don’t have to be limited to that.
We’ll also discuss the difference between patent rejections and objections.
Before we get started, one important reminder: Please don’t share confidential details about your invention during the live broadcast. Instead, schedule a conversation with us or one of our advisors. Dallas Richardson is a great person to start with. You can schedule a free 20-minute screening session to discuss your situation.
And if you’re interested in learning more about intellectual property, we’ll also send you a free PDF copy of our inventor’s guide.
Let’s jump into patents.
Understanding the Patent Application Process
J.D.: I gave Matt about two minutes’ warning that we’d be discussing office actions today, so I’m going to jump right in.
This chart illustrates what can happen during the patent application process at the USPTO.
Let’s start at the beginning.
You file your non-provisional patent application. Many inventors start by filing a provisional application, which can happen up to a year before the non-provisional application.
Once you submit the formal non-provisional application, the examination process begins.
You’ll generally receive an electronic filing acknowledgment shortly after submission, confirming that the USPTO has received your application. Then, usually one to two months later, you’ll receive an official filing receipt confirming the application details.
Sometimes, the USPTO identifies formalities that need attention. Maybe a document wasn’t submitted correctly, or a fee wasn’t paid. These are administrative issues that may need to be resolved before the application progresses.
Another possibility is receiving what’s called a restriction requirement.
This happens when the examiner believes your application covers more than one distinct invention. The examiner may require you to choose which invention or species you want to pursue in that particular application. Other subject matter may be pursued separately.
When Your Patent Application Becomes Public
J.D.: Another important milestone is publication.
Generally, patent applications are published 18 months after the earliest claimed priority date.
For example, let’s say you file a provisional application on January 1, 2020. You then file your non-provisional application a year later. Approximately six months after that, your application would typically be published.
That means the public can access the application, even if the patent hasn’t been granted yet.
There is a process called a non-publication request that may allow an eligible application to remain unpublished. However, there are important limitations, particularly concerning foreign patent filings.
If confidentiality is important to your strategy, that’s something to discuss with a patent professional before filing.
What Happens When the USPTO Issues an Office Action?
J.D.: Now we get to the examination itself.
Once the examiner has reviewed your application and conducted a search, you’ll generally receive an office action. One common outcome is a non-final rejection.
It’s relatively uncommon for an application to go straight to a notice of allowance.
Instead, the examiner may find prior art and determine that your invention isn’t new or that the differences between your invention and existing references would have been obvious.
There are two common grounds to understand:
- Novelty: The examiner believes the invention isn’t new because an earlier reference already describes the claimed subject matter.
- Obviousness: The examiner believes the claimed invention would have been obvious based on one or more existing references.
The examiner explains the reasoning, and you have an opportunity to respond within the applicable deadline.
Matt: And this is where having someone who understands the examination process can make a difference.
J.D.: Exactly. You don’t necessarily have to accept the examiner’s first conclusion.
You can prepare an office action response, present legal arguments, make amendments to your claims, and sometimes request an interview with the examiner.
That interview can be valuable. You get to speak directly with the examiner, understand how they’re interpreting your claims, and discuss what might overcome the objections or rejections.
What Happens After a Final Rejection?
J.D.: Eventually, the examiner may issue what’s called a final rejection.
A lot of inventors see the word final and feel deflated.
They think, “That’s it. I’ve spent all this money, and now my invention is rejected.”
But is it really game over?
Not necessarily.
You may have the option to file a Request for Continued Examination, commonly called an RCE. This allows prosecution to continue after a final rejection, subject to the applicable requirements and fees.
You can make additional amendments, present further arguments, and potentially conduct another interview.
Sometimes, the examiner may reconsider the claims after reviewing your revised arguments. A supervising examiner may also become involved.
It’s often a back-and-forth process. You refine the claims, address the examiner’s concerns, and work toward an agreement on what can be allowed.
Eventually, the examiner may agree to allow the claims, and the application can proceed toward patent issuance.
Matt: That’s a lot of work.
J.D.: It is! And the process can take two to three years or sometimes longer.
One additional strategy worth discussing is filing a continuation application before the original patent application issues. This can help preserve the opportunity to pursue other claim scope supported by the original disclosure.
So don’t assume that a final rejection means you’ve reached the end of the road.
Can You Trademark Slogans and Common Phrases?
J.D.: Let’s see what questions we have from the audience.
Charlie has a question:
“I have several slogans and a colloquialism that I need trademarked. What’s the pathway for protecting them?”
Matt, let’s jump over to trademarks.
Matt: Sure! Thanks for the question, Charlie.
Slogans and everyday sayings can potentially qualify for federal trademark registration, depending on how they’re used.
For example, let’s say you have a phrase like “You Betcha.” Here in Minnesota, that’s something people say all the time.
If you put that phrase on a T-shirt and use it to identify the source of your apparel, you might be able to register it as a trademark.
However, there’s a catch.
If a phrase is so commonplace that consumers don’t associate it with a particular brand, it may be difficult to register. We need to look at how widely the phrase is used and whether consumers would recognize it as identifying a particular source of goods or services.
J.D.: So how would somebody like Charlie get started?
Matt: The first step would be to have a conversation about the products, the business, and what they’re trying to accomplish.
You’d probably start by speaking with Dallas, who could connect you with me.
We would conduct an initial search through the USPTO database to see whether there are potential conflicts with the proposed trademark.
If the initial search looks promising, we can move forward with a more comprehensive trademark search and legal opinion.
From there, we can prepare the application and move forward with the registration process.
J.D.: Excellent. Thanks, Matt.
How Do Companies Like Apple Keep Their Patents Secret?
J.D.: We have another question from Justin:
“What does Apple do with its secretive patents?”
Well, I don’t work at Apple, and I don’t represent Apple, but I can explain one strategy companies may use.
There is a way to request non-publication of an eligible U.S. patent application.
Essentially, the applicant asks the USPTO not to publish the application.
However, there are important trade-offs. A non-publication request generally requires the applicant to certify that the invention won’t be the subject of a corresponding foreign or international application, subject to applicable rules.
So you’re making a strategic decision about where you want protection.
If a company believes the U.S. market is its primary market for a particular invention, it might consider that approach.
But companies need to evaluate the international implications carefully.
Matt: I can add something from the trademark side.
Large multinational companies sometimes use affiliated companies or subsidiaries when filing trademark applications for new products.
For example, a company might have a separate legal entity that owns or files for protection of a particular brand.
This can make it harder for competitors to immediately identify who is behind a new product or what the company is preparing to launch.
Think about a company preparing to introduce a major new product. It may not want competitors to know the product name before the official announcement.
One possible strategy is to file through an affiliated company or use an available foreign filing strategy before bringing the application into the United States.
J.D.: Let’s make up an example.
Instead of launching an iPhone 15, let’s say Apple decides to introduce something called the iPhone Glaze.
Maybe an affiliated company files for trademark protection for Glaze in another country.
Then, subject to the applicable priority rules and deadlines, the company could seek U.S. protection based on that earlier foreign application.
Matt: Exactly. The company may be able to keep its involvement less obvious while preparing to launch the product.
J.D.: Interesting strategy!
GeoOrbital: The Electric Bicycle Wheel That Appeared on Shark Tank
J.D.: All right, let’s move on to our Bold Bite.
We’ve got a short clip featuring GeoOrbital, an electric bicycle wheel that appeared on Shark Tank.
The company introduced a product designed to turn an ordinary bicycle into an electric bicycle in under 60 seconds, without tools.
In the clip, the founders explain how the product works and demonstrate the technology to the Sharks.
The GeoOrbital Wheel
GeoOrbital Founders (Video Clip): Our company is GeoOrbital, and we’re from Cambridge, Massachusetts.
We’re asking for $500,000 in exchange for 5% of our company.
Bicycles have remained relatively unchanged for more than 100 years. We wanted to bring them into the 21st century.
We created a way to turn almost any bicycle electric in under 60 seconds, without using tools.
You simply remove the regular front wheel, install the GeoOrbital wheel, attach the throttle, and you’re ready to go.
The wheel can take you from zero to 20 miles per hour in under 10 seconds, with a range of up to 20 miles on a single charge without pedaling.
It also provides 500 watts of power to help you climb hills.
Shark: So, can I try it?
GeoOrbital Founders: Absolutely!
Shark: And how much are you selling it for?
GeoOrbital Founders: The wheel retails for $950.
Shark: Isn’t it cheaper to buy an electric bike?
GeoOrbital Founders: It depends on the bike. You can certainly find electric bikes for less, but it’s also about the quality and the opportunity to upgrade a bicycle you already own.
Shark: Would you ever make your own bike?
GeoOrbital Founders: We don’t currently make bikes. We’ve created something different: an electric wheel that can be installed on an existing bicycle.
We also have a compact electric bike that is extremely nimble and can fit in the trunk of a car.
Matt’s Take: Why Trademark Protection Matters
Matt: That’s a cool invention! I like the concept.
But I have to say, the name is terrible!
I don’t know what GeoOrbital means. It doesn’t immediately communicate anything about bicycles or electric wheels.
J.D.: Well, at least they’ve got trademark protection.
Matt: They do! The GeoOrbital name is registered as a federal trademark for powered bicycle wheels.
That’s important. They’ve taken steps to protect the brand associated with their product.
However, I noticed that they haven’t registered their logo, which is something they could consider.
I’d also look at how they’re protecting their online store and other branding assets, especially since their website appears to be an important sales channel.
J.D.: That’s a good point. A product can have a great invention behind it, but you also need to think about protecting the business identity you’re building around that invention.
J.D.’s Take: GeoOrbital’s Patent Application Was Abandoned
J.D.: I dug into the patent history, and this is where things get really interesting.
Remember, today’s topic is office actions.
One thing you’ll sometimes see business owners do is get a little ahead of themselves when describing their products.
For example, GeoOrbital was described as having a patented wheel.
But when I looked up its patent application through the USPTO Patent Center, I found that the application had actually been abandoned.
The application dates back to 2013, and the examination process provides a useful example of what can happen when an inventor doesn’t respond to an office action.
Anyone can look up publicly available patent application records. You don’t have to be a patent attorney to access the information.
You can go to the USPTO’s Patent Center, locate the application, and review its documents and transactions.
Let’s walk through what I found.
The company initially filed its application in 2013.
The USPTO acknowledged the filing, and there were some additional submissions and paperwork along the way.
Eventually, in 2015, the examiner completed the review and issued a non-final rejection.
When you open the office action, you can see the status of the claims.
Claims 1 through 20 were still pending at that point. Some claims were rejected, while others were objected to.
The drawings were accepted, which is another important distinction. Sometimes drawings themselves can be objected to if they don’t meet the USPTO’s requirements.
But the main problem was with the claims.
The Prior Art Rejections
J.D.: The examiner rejected the claims under Section 102 of the Patent Act, which deals with novelty.
The examiner cited an earlier reference from 2005 that described an electric motor arrangement involving a wheel and axle.
The examiner’s position was essentially that the claimed invention wasn’t sufficiently different from what had already been disclosed.
The examiner also raised an obviousness rejection under Section 103, relying on another reference from 2008.
In other words, the examiner was saying that even if the invention could overcome the first reference, combining the teachings of the cited references could still make the claims obvious.
There was a lot to review and respond to.
But here’s what really surprised me: the application wasn’t successfully prosecuted through that rejection. It eventually became abandoned.
The applicant had an opportunity to respond to the office action within the applicable response period, but the application was not carried forward.
Matt: That’s unfortunate, especially considering how innovative the product was.
J.D.: Absolutely.
It’s possible the business was going through changes or that the company had other priorities at the time. We don’t know exactly what happened.
But it’s a good reminder that getting a great product off the ground doesn’t automatically mean you’ll successfully obtain a patent.
You have to manage the intellectual property process, respond to the USPTO, and keep the application moving.
Matt’s Breakdown: GeoOrbital’s Trademark Application
Matt: Let’s look at the trademark side of the story.
J.D. showed you the patent application and what happened during patent prosecution.
Now let’s look at GeoOrbital’s trademark file.
The trademark application was filed in December 2014 and eventually registered in 2017.
But there was quite a bit happening between those two dates.
When you look at the trademark file history, you’ll see the original application, the drawing showing the brand name, and the USPTO’s examination records.
The USPTO conducted its search and issued an office action.
This was a relatively minor office action compared with what we saw on the patent side.
The trademark examiner wanted clarification about the actual product being offered.
Essentially, the applicant needed to clarify the identification of the goods.
You’ll also see an examiner’s amendment, where the examining attorney made changes to the application, followed by publication and statements of use as the application progressed.
Why Are There So Many Address Changes?
Matt: One thing that caught my attention was the number of address changes in the file.
There were also several changes involving attorneys.
J.D.: Why would that happen?
Matt: It could be that the company was changing locations or headquarters. It also looks like they changed attorneys fairly frequently.
I didn’t see an assignment history showing that the trademark itself had been transferred to another company.
It’s possible that there were business transactions or changes behind the scenes that weren’t reflected as a trademark assignment.
We would need more research to know exactly what happened.
J.D.: Interesting.
Matt: It’s a great example of why you should look beyond just whether a trademark or patent exists.
You want to understand the actual application history and what happened along the way.
Can You Revive an Abandoned Patent Application?
J.D.: There’s one more important point I want inventors to understand.
Even if an application becomes abandoned, that doesn’t necessarily mean there’s no possibility of bringing it back.
Under certain circumstances, you may be able to petition the USPTO to revive an abandoned application.
There are specific requirements, deadlines, and certifications involved. The reason for missing the response deadline matters.
For example, there may be circumstances involving an unintentional delay or other qualifying situations that could support a petition.
If the petition is granted, the applicant may be able to continue prosecution and respond to the outstanding office action.
However, there are important considerations.
For example, if an application was abandoned for a period of time, there may be consequences concerning potential intervening rights and the ability to recover damages for infringement.
You need to evaluate the specific application history and the applicable law before assuming that revival will restore every potential right.
Matt: And the same general concept exists on the trademark side.
There are situations where an abandoned trademark application may be eligible for revival, depending on the circumstances and applicable requirements.
But when it comes to office actions, responding on time is always important.
J.D.: Exactly. Don’t ignore those USPTO notices.
If you receive an office action, understand what the examiner is asking for and get help if you need it.
Final Thoughts: Don’t Let an Office Action Stop Your Invention
J.D.: We’re getting toward the end of our show.
Thanks to Justin and Charlie for joining us live and asking great questions.
Whether you’re watching live or catching up after the broadcast, we appreciate you being here.
We’re live every week at 1:30 Pacific and 4:30 Eastern, discussing patents, trademarks, copyrights, and other intellectual property topics.
We’d also love to have you join the conversation and bring your questions.
Matt: Absolutely. If you have questions about trademarks or protecting your brand, feel free to reach out.
J.D.: And if you’re dealing with a patent office action, don’t assume that a rejection means your invention is finished.
There may be ways to respond, amend your claims, and continue pursuing protection.
Thanks again, Matt, for joining me today.
Matt: Thanks, J.D.!
J.D.: All right, everybody. Go big, go bold!









